Reports Apr 7, 2015 | 9:31 AMby Colin McGourty

US Champs R5: Nakamura, So and Kamsky all win

Wesley So poses proudly with his chocolate Easter bunny before taking a bite out of his opponent | photo: Lennart Ootes, official website

The players were gifted chocolate bunnies for Easter Sunday, but it was Hikaru Nakamura, Wesley So and Gata Kamsky who made their US Championship opponents look like rabbits caught in headlights with one-sided wins in Round 5. Kayden Troff added some unpredictability by pulling off a miraculous turnaround against Conrad Holt, while Irina Krush lived dangerously before moving within half a point of leader Katerina Nemcova in the women’s event.

After a very shaky two rounds, no. 1 seed Hikaru Nakamura beat Daniel Naroditsky to become the sole leader of the US Championship on 4/5, half a point ahead of Wesley So. He also regained the live no. 2 ranking from Fabiano Caruana. 

Norwegian Grandmaster Jon Ludvig Hammer summed up the game:

Nakamura played the Dragon Sicilian and then went for the traditional exchange sacrifice on c3 at an unexpected moment:

14.Rxc3!? Nakamura himself admitted it was perhaps objectively losing, but he’d sensed weakness in his 19-year-old opponent, who started the day in bottom place after a miserable tournament so far. 

Nakamura in menacing mood | photo: Austin Fuller, official website

Sure enough, Hikaru had already gained an advantage before Naroditsky self-destructed with 28.e5?

After 28…dxe5 he was forced to give up an exchange with 29.Rxe5, since 29.Bxe5, perhaps his intention, simply loses on the spot to 29…Bh6, skewering the rook. The rest was easy for Nakamura, who talked to Maurice Ashley after the game:

Wesley So’s game was less dramatic. Timur Gareev tried to live up to his reputation for outrageous openings with an early h5 in the French Defence, but gradually lost one pawn and then another. 

Wesley So didn't let Timur Gareev's shirt gambit distract him | photo: Spectrum, official website

The most memorable moment of the whole game was the final position:

Wesley So is of course winning, but both queen and knight endings are tricky and the white pawns are scattered to the wind, so he was puzzled when after eight minutes’ thought Gareev came up to him and offered his hand. If you watch only one video from this round make it So’s interview where he explains that he’s a gentleman so he felt obliged to shake his opponent’s hand although he wasn’t sure if he’d get a 1 or a 1/2 on the scoresheet!

The other big hitter in the Championship is 40-year-old reigning champion Gata Kamsky, who seems to be building up momentum. His opponent, Ray Robson, had been flying high, but his position crumbled in time trouble:

Everything seems to be just about holding for Black, but the final move of the game, 38.Rxd8!, destroyed any illusions. After the only move 38…Qxd8 39.Nh5+! wins the house.

Photographic evidence suggests Ray Robson had seen the final blow... | photo: Lennart Ootes, official website

In his interview Gata made clear he still has chess ambitions, with his main goal in the tournament being to qualify for the World Cup in Baku later this year (there are five places up for grabs), since that’s a route to a possible World Championship match. He also talked about how one of the other games was simply too wild for him:

The game that had Gata scratching his head was Conrad Holt – Kayden Troff (don’t miss replaying it in our broadcast). 

Conrad Holt was the unfortunate winner of the day's "find the worst move on the board" contest | photo: Lennart Ootes, official website

With the impetuousness of youth 16-year-old Troff went for a wild line since he couldn’t actually see a refutation. There was one – or in fact there were many – but if Troff had been less adventurous we’d have been denied a truly tragi-comic conclusion to the game:

Conrad Holt has just played the disastrous 43.Kh3?? – the only one of the five king moves at his disposal that wasn’t winning! It’s a very understandable mistake, since there are no more checks and it looks as though Qd6+ is a resource that will extinguish any black threats, but no... 43…g5!! turned the tables. White has no good way to stop the threat of Qh6+ mate, since putting any piece on d6 runs into g4+, Kh4 and a knight fork on f5 (the game went 44.Rd6 g4+ 45.Kh4 Nf5+), and 44.g4 Qh6+ 45.Kg3 runs into another fork, 45…Nf1+.

Truly unfortunate for Holt, but Troff’s joy at realising he was suddenly winning is infectious!

The two remaining games were drawn, including another bold game by 14-year-old Sam Sevian, who had his similarly named 23-year-old opponent Sam Shankland sweating for a while. Shankland’s interview was another classic on a great day for the TV coverage, with his downbeat and funny assessment of his play so far combining nicely with the (enjoyably) over-the-top enthusiasm of the US broadcast. It included some great one-liners:

Watch the full interview:

The standings at the midway point are as follows:

1GM Nakamura, Hikaru4.027982891+0.5511½½1
2GM So, Wesley3.527882794+0.07110½1
3GM Kamsky, Gata3.026832722+0.28½½½½1
4GM Robson, Ray3.026562678+0.161½1½0
5GM Troff, Kayden W3.025322701+1.1601½½1
6GM Onischuk, Alexander2.526652589-0.51½½½½½
7GM Akobian, Varuzhan2.526222651+0.1910½½½
8GM Sevian, Samuel2.525312677+0.960½1½½
9GM Shankland, Samuel L2.026612561-0.69½0½½½
10GM Gareev, Timur1.526042509-0.64½0½½0
11GM Holt, Conrad1.525302502-0.22010½0
12GM Naroditsky, Daniel1.026332422-1.3100½½0

In the women’s event Katerina Nemcova continues to lead on 4/5 after a draw against Tatev Abrahayan, but 6-time Champion Irina Krush is now in sole second place after a crucial victory to leapfrog Rusudan Goletiani. 

Can Irina Krush come back to win her fourth title in a row? | photo: Lennart Ootes, official website

It was anything but easy, with Irina admitting she’d relied too much on general principles when she allowed 19…Bxh3!. Rusudan was soon on top, but she got too clever with 22…Bxg2?, when she could in fact have taken the rook on e5:

Here 23.Rh5! Qxh5 24.Qd4+! turned the tables, although that was far from the end of the story, since Irina let her opponent equalise again before finally taking home the full point. Watch her description of the game:

So the standings in the women’s event are as follows:

1WGM Nemcova, Katerina4.022792447+1.11½111½
2GM Krush, Irina3.524772389-0.44½1011
3IM Paikidze, Nazi3.023332347+0.12½½1½½
4IM Goletiani, Rusudan3.023112374+0.44½11½0
5WGM Foisor, Sabina-Francesca3.022352310+0.56½011½
6WGM Abrahamyan, Tatev2.523222150-1.040011½
7WCM Virkud, Apurva2.521322309+1.111½001
8WGM Sharevich, Anna2.022672171-0.66100½½
9FM Melekhina, Alisa2.022352158-0.5401½0½
10WIM Ni, Viktorija2.021882186-0.03½00½1
11WFM Yu, Jennifer R1.521802022-1.0201½00
12WIM Wang, Annie1.019011997+0.3910000

On Tuesday night battle recommences in St. Louis, with the top young American hopes taking on the established stars in Nakamura – Shankland and Robson – So, the veterans facing off in Onischuk – Kamsky and the teenagers playing for bragging rights in Troff – Sevian. Don’t miss it!

Follow all the action live here on chess24 from 20:00 CEST. You can also watch the games on our free mobile apps:


See also:

Sort by Date Descending Date Descending Date Ascending Most Liked Receive updates

Comments 1

Guest 9329394163
Join chess24
  • Free, Quick & Easy

  • Be the first to comment!


Create your free account now to get started!

By clicking ‘Register’ you agree to our terms and conditions and confirm you have read our privacy policy, including the section on the use of cookies.

Lost your password? We'll send you a link to reset it!

After submitting this form you'll receive an email with the reset password link. If you still can't access your account please contact our customer service.

Which features would you like to enable?

We respect your privacy and data protection guidelines. Some components of our site require cookies or local storage that handles personal information.

Show Options

Hide Options