Reports Sep 17, 2017 | 8:17 AMby Colin McGourty

Tbilisi World Cup, QF 2: So, Ding & Aronian in semis

Wesley So and Ding Liren meet in the semifinals of the 2017 World Cup after giving masterclasses with the white pieces to win their quarterfinal matches against Vladimir Fedoseev and Richard Rapport. Levon Aronian joins them after Vassily Ivanchuk put up a great fight in the second game but was ultimately unable to prevent a draw. His opponent will be either Peter Svidler or Maxime Vachier-Lagrave (“I hate them both!”) after they played out a tense draw with mutual chances and now go into tiebreaks on Sunday.

Aronian conducting his pieces, or perhaps getting in a little exercise... | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

You can replay all the games from the FIDE World Cup in Tbilisi using the selector below. Click on a result to open the game with computer analysis or hover over a player’s name to see all his or her results:

Draws are OK! Learn to love the draw by taking out a 1-year Premium Membership, picking a World Cup player and getting a free month of Premium for every draw he makes at classical chess! Details here

Ivanchuk goes out with his head held high

Vassily Ivanchuk’s army of fans were worried after his loss to Levon Aronian in the first game of their match. It wasn’t so much the fact of losing to the Armenian no. 1, which could happen to anyone, but the way it occurred – the reckless time management, poor decision-making and premature resignation. Could the mercurial Ukrainian pull himself together and at least make a fight of the second game?

The World Championship dream slips away again for Ivanchuk | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

The opening didn’t inspire confidence, since by move 15 the white queen had spent five moves just to crawl back into its hole, while Black was fully developed with advanced pawns and pieces:

Vassily was playing fast and commentator Ivan Sokolov concluded that the most likely explanation for that was that “his nerves are gone”. From there on, though, there was no collapse, and it gradually became clear that although the opening hadn’t gone particularly well, Ivanchuk was doing exactly what he had to do in such a situation – maintaining the tension and avoiding exchanging pieces. White had long-term potential in the bishop pair and, in a complete reversal of fortunes from the day before, was almost an hour up on the clock:

Aronian would later comment:

Such games are always tense, so I expected this and I knew that I had to have the intensity to pass through. I was trying to play my best but still, I think I was playing too slow at some point. I should have played faster, and then my opponent was trying to exploit that fact.

Vassily later pushed the d-pawn to d5, where it was lost, but even a pawn down his bishop pair and active rooks gave full compensation and even a slight edge. The moment at which Levon felt he was out of danger, though, was when Ivanchuk played 50.Bc1:

Levon explained:

At one moment when I played 49…Bc5 I felt his 50.Bc1 was too passive. I felt he should have gone for 50.Bf4. It would give him more chances to fight, because once I play 50…g5 I’m released of any danger, generally, and then I can play with my hand. That’s always a pleasure - when you’re in time trouble just not to have a position where you have to carefully watch out for threats.

The game went on for another 21 moves, but with material exhausted Vassily conceded defeat on move 71 and world no. 4 (or no. 2 on the live rating list) Levon Aronian was in the semifinals of the 2017 World Cup. His opponent there will be either Peter Svidler or Maxime Vachier-Lagrave. When asked who he’d prefer, Aronian quipped:

I hate them both! Both are very, very annoying opponents, so let’s see who proves to be worthier.

Watch Anastasia Karlovich’s interview with Levon:

Tiebreaks for Svidler and MVL

Levon also commented when asked if he was tired:

I’m fine! You know, it’s kind of a thing, you either work really hard and have a rest day, or you just relax and have a tiebreak.

Neither of those scenarios applies to Peter Svidler and Maxime Vachier-Lagrave, who played out a second relatively quick but extremely tense draw that could easily have proven decisive. 

Another day, another fierce battle, another draw | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

The Giuoco Piano, as is the latest trend, was anything but quiet, and with the innocent-looking 18.Kh2 Maxime threw down the gauntlet to his opponent:

You don’t need to be Peter Svidler to see that 18…Bxd4 19.cxd4 Qxb5 wins a pawn, but it was also clear that White would in return get a huge pawn centre and significant attacking chances. After 11 minutes’ thought Peter went for 18…Re7, with MVL choosing to challenge that rook with 19.Ndf5. Svidler didn’t retreat but advanced the rook with 19…Re6?!

This is a scary position, with 20.Nxg7 or 20.Nxh6+ followed by 21.f5 very serious options, while it turns out preparing Nxg7 with 20.Qd2! may be even stronger. Peter Svidler’s fans held their breath, and couldn’t relax when MVL’s 20.Nd4!? was met by 20…Re7. It was the penultimate round of the Sinquefield Cup all over again, when Aronian and Svidler had repeated moves in a position laced with peril. 

Will Maxime live to regret his missed chance? | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

Eventually, though, MVL went for 21.b4!?, which would have been stronger when the knight was on f5. Now Svidler could finally take on d4 and grab the b5-pawn with 21…Bxd4 22.cxd4 Qxb5. When 23.f5 was played it was accompanied by a draw offer.

Svidler decided to play on with his extra pawn, but finally offered a draw himself after 27…Re8:

He couldn’t see how to make progress, while White still had the potential to whip up an attack on the black king. Maxime accepted and it was the kind of draw after which both players breathe a sigh of relief. That match now goes to tiebreaks, while the remaining two encounters were decided on Saturday.

Ding Liren’s justified confidence

The flow of upsets that had seen us lose the likes of Carlsen, Caruana, Mamedyarov, Anand, Nakamura and Karjakin had already dried up in Round 4 and in the quarterfinals we’ve seen the current elite players demonstrating exactly why they have that status. Whatever happens in Sunday’s tiebreak we’ll have only 2750+ rated Top 15 players in the semifinals.

Ding Liren took revenge for his Chinese colleagues Wei Yi and Li Chao, who had lost to Rapport earlier in the event | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

Underdogs Richard Rapport and Vladimir Fedoseev both made quick draws with the white pieces in the first game of their quarterfinals and both lived to regret it in the second. Ding Liren explained of accepting a draw offer against Rapport:

Yesterday I know maybe my position is equal and maybe slightly better, but I think I’m confident with my white pieces so I will try to push with White.

He got off to the perfect start by managing to play a near novelty with 9.Re1:

It doesn’t look in any way remarkable, but in 755 games this had been played just once in an insignificant encounter between lower-rated players, while 9.Rc1 had been seen 529 times. It was already here that Rapport went astray, with Ding Liren calling 9…a6?! “a very strange move”, and one he set out to punish immediately with 10.Ne5. The Chinese grandmaster also criticised the passive 12…d6 (12…c5! was his suggestion) and soon Black’s position began to fall apart. The sequence 14…b5 15.Qe2! bxc4 16.d5! Qc8 culminated in 17.e5!, a move which took Ding 22 minutes and which he considered the critical moment of the game:

There followed 17…exd5 18.exd6! and here Black was forced to play 18…cxd6 and give up a piece on e7, since as Ding Liren explained afterwards he’d seen 18…Bxd6 19.Qf3! Nc6 20.Bxg7! and if Black takes the bishop it’s mate-in-2. 

Black is also lost after other moves, with the threat of Qxd5 looming.

The end of the road for Richard Rapport in Tbilisi | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

In the game Rapport showed some tactical ingenuity of his own to recover the lost piece, but he could only do it at the cost of entering a lost rook ending. Ding Liren commented:

I thought I would win immediately after 20.Qe4, but I missed 20…Qc6, but fortunately the position’s still much better for me and I can play very simply. After he exchanged the queens I played very simply and the rook endgame is very unpleasant for him.

Rapport resigned on move 41 and his fine World Cup was over.

Ding Liren now has two rest days before he faces Wesley So in the semifinals. You can watch his post-game interview below:

Wesley So: “No-one wants to go home”

The opening went according to Fedoseev's plan, but So proved better equipped to play the ensuing position | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

Wesley So summed up his victory over Vladimir Fedoseev:

It’s very tough to beat somebody, because no-one wants to go home. I think it’s also very tough for my opponent, but at the end of the day someone has got to win, and I especially don’t want to go yet. So I tried really hard today. It’s really good that I managed to convert this and I’d like to thank the Lord for letting me win the match. I didn’t really expect to win today because Vladimir Fedoseev is a very good player and everybody notices he’s gained like 80 points in the last 5 months and he prepared really well today. At some point I thought the game was just going to end in a draw.

The opening was a Petroff Defence, and although Vassily Ivanchuk had once lost the position after 15 moves with Black he’d done it in a blindfold rapid game in the Amber chess tournament. Plus, as Wesley mentioned, Fedoseev was clearly better prepared and continued to play instantly until move 20. Almost immediately after he was on his own, though, So felt that his opponent was too aggressive, describing 21…g5!? as “more than a little bit risky” with queens still on the board, while 23.Be7? was a clear mistake:

Wesley felt that instead 23…Rf7 and 24…Re7 would have been a draw, but now the undermining 24.h4! was possible, since the knight must stay on g6 to defend the bishop. After 24…gxh4 25.Nf4! Rf7 26.Qe6! Qxe6 27.Rxe6 Nxf4 28.Bxf4 Bd8 29.b4! Kg7 30. bxa5 bxa5 Fedoseev suddenly found himself stuck in a miserable ending with weaknesses on both sides of the board:

Against as brilliant a technical player as Wesley So it was real credit to Vladimir Fedoseev that he managed to stay in the game so long, but while Wesley failed to find a way through with rooks and bishops on the board he then gradually realised that the bishop ending was very good for him. 

Where will Vladimir Fedoseev go from here? | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

He swapped off rooks and felt the game was essentially over when Fedoseev put his king on c6 rather than e6. All he needed to do was put his bishop on e5, and though it took a long and circuitous route it finally got there! 

Black's position then soon fell apart. Watch Wesley talking about the game:

That impressive victory against a player who’s well and truly announced his arrival on the world stage means that Wesley So now plays Ding Liren in a World Cup semifinal that starts on Tuesday. Although only lasting two games as in the other rounds, the semifinals are arguably much more important than the final match, since both finalists will already have qualified for the Candidates Tournament. Either Wesley So or Ding Liren will qualify for the first time, and if Wesley does it then Fabiano Caruana and Vladimir Kramnik will be almost guaranteed to play in the Candidates as well as rating qualifiers.

Wesley So is one match win away from the Candidates | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

Wesley noted that he lost a match to Ding Liren in China last year after losing one game with three draws, but as he also noted, “a lot of water has flowed under the bridge since then”. Something will have to give, since both Wesley and Ding Liren are unbeaten in Tbilisi so far.

So-Ding Liren was tough to predict (only 30 out of 1416 managed!) but one prediction to get that right, Magical Magyars, currently leads our Prediction contest - it predicts MVL getting to the semis before Aronian wins a final against Ding Liren!

That’s not all for the quarterfinal action, though, since Peter Svidler and Maxime Vachier-Lagrave must still play tiebreaks to determine who takes on Levon Aronian in the semifinal. Catch all the games here on chess24 from 13:00 CEST onwards

You can also follow the games in our free mobile apps:


See more:

Sort by Date Descending Date Descending Date Ascending Most Liked Receive updates

Comments 7

Guest 12100765393
Join chess24
  • Free, Quick & Easy

  • Be the first to comment!


Create your free account now to get started!

By clicking ‘Register’ you agree to our terms and conditions and confirm you have read our privacy policy, including the section on the use of cookies.

Lost your password? We'll send you a link to reset it!

After submitting this form you'll receive an email with the reset password link. If you still can't access your account please contact our customer service.

Which features would you like to enable?

We respect your privacy and data protection guidelines. Some components of our site require cookies or local storage that handles personal information.

Show Options

Hide Options