Reports Sep 15, 2017 | 6:43 PMby Colin McGourty

Tbilisi World Cup, QF 1: Ivanchuk meltdown

Levon Aronian is off to a winning start in the FIDE World Cup quarterfinals after he caught Vassily Ivanchuk out in the opening and called the move his opponent eventually made after a 42-minute think on move 10, “a bit suicidal”. From then on Chucky played even faster than he had to until abruptly resigning on move 24 in a position where there was still material equality. Elsewhere Fedoseev-So and Rapport-Ding Liren gave themselves a rest day with quick draws, while MVL wriggled out of a tough position against Peter Svidler.

And this was before Chucky's torture began... | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

You can replay all the FIDE World Cup games using the selector below – click a result to open the game with computer analysis or hover over a player’s name to see all his or her results:

A Chucky moment

Was it all down to the lack of a lucky pen? | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

Up until this point in the 2017 FIDE World Cup Vassily Ivanchuk had been superb. He needed tiebreaks against his first two opponents, but didn’t lose a game, with the only eccentricity being that he arrived a few minutes late to one of his encounters with Poland’s Jan-Krzysztof Duda. Then we witnessed phenomenal victories over Vladimir Kramnik and Anish Giri, with the win with the black pieces against Kramnik an almost flawless demonstration of technique. He’d earned a rest day to prepare for his quarterfinal against Levon Aronian.

Levon has converted Ivanchuk into something approaching his client, though they've met relatively rarely in recent years | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

The classical record between Ivanchuk and Aronian before their game in Tbilisi was +1 in Vassily’s favour, with 12 wins to 11 and 16 draws. That didn’t tell the full story though, with Levon mentioning their score in an interview earlier this year:

Does the problem of difficult opponents exist at the elite level, or is it just a string of bad luck which happens to affect encounters with particular opponents?

Levon Aronian: It definitely exists. You often witness how one chess player scores a clean sweep against another, and from a psychological point of view it’s held that you play very strongly if you’re used to beating a particular opponent. A lot still depends on the opening, when you get positions that you like, while your opponent is simply playing “your” opening – that’s a fashion just now – and hasn’t got round to coming up with his own.

In principle, though, it’s a problem you can fight against. At some point I had a terrible “minus” against Ivanchuk, while now it seems it’s not bad at all (smiles). I recall it was -7 or maybe even -8, but I’ve managed to return that to somewhere in the region of -1 or -2.

Levon did that, of course, by beating Ivanchuk. After Ivanchuk won both their games in Linares in 2009, Aronian went on to win 6 classical games to Ivanchuk’s 1, including both their games in the 2013 Candidates Tournament. That may have been at the back of Ivanchuk’s mind in the run-up to the match, though on the other hand, Levon has this year shown he can make anyone, including the likes of Magnus Carlsen and Wesley So, look foolish at the chessboard.

Levon played the English Opening and, up to a point, it seemed uneventful except that Ivanchuk had begun to think on move 2 and both players had used up a reasonable amount of time when Ivanchuk made the move 9…a6? rather than developing one of his kingside pieces. The question mark after the move could only be added confidently after what happened next, since the “0.12 Equal” evaluation of Stockfish 8 at a depth of 22 was giving nothing away, and Ivanchuk only spent a minute and a half on the move. And then came 10.d4!

And in this outwardly innocent looking position Vassily sank into a think that lasted 42 minutes and 39 seconds and must have grown increasingly bitter. Levon explained what his opponent was thinking about:

I think by that moment he realised he misplayed the opening, because Black is not able to play c5, simply, and if he doesn’t then I play Ne5 and the position is rather unpleasant. It would have been more practical, of course, for Black to proceed with the passive Nf6, Be7, but that position is very, very pleasant for White. White just puts the rook on d1 and just maybe some Bg5. I don’t think Black is in time to play c5, so it would be a very passive position… which I thought Vassily would do.

Instead Ivanchuk went for 10…c5?!, which Aronian described as, “a bit suicidal”, though he saw why Vassily nevertheless played it:

I think it was more or less a principled position. Black has done everything to play c5 and now he has this position where if he doesn’t he’s still in real trouble.

Aronian wasted no time in replying with 11.d5! and after 11…exd5 the key move 12.Nh4!

The d5-pawn is attacked and the pin along the h1-a8 diagonal paralyses Black's position. Ivanchuk must have foreseen it, but he now took his last think of the game, spending 8 minutes on 12…Ndf6!? Curiously this is the first new move of the game, since Sofio Gvetadze played the more natural 12…Ngf6 against Thi Thanh An Nguyen in the 2007 Women’s World Team Championship. She drew that game, and while that was a far less likely outcome against a player of Levon Aronian’s calibre, the move does look more convincing. Perhaps Ivanchuk was “pragmatically” attempting to get his opponent out of his opening preparation. If that was the case, there were some issues… First, the clock:

Secondly, Aronian’s play flowed naturally and he wasn’t going to make things any easier for his opponent by taking a long think of his own. Vassily now blitzed out his moves and may have overlooked some important nuances before reaching the following position after 24.d6:

There’s no reason to doubt the verdict that Black is lost, but there are still few players in world chess who would have chosen this moment to resign, as Ivanchuk did.

"I didn't really trick him", commented Aronian, explaining his opponent had just made a mistake in an old theoretical line | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

Material is equal in a complicated position with many pieces remaining on the board and, more importantly, this is the first game of a World Cup quarterfinal match. Even if the odds of saving the game were 5% it would surely have made sense to play on for a while rather than meekly accept a tough match situation. Ivanchuk must now win with White on Saturday or he’s out of the 2017 FIDE World Cup.

Vassily has bounced back from similar opening debacles - this is Wijk aan Zee in 2015 - but the problem in Tbilisi is he needs to do it very fast | photo: Alina l'Ami, Tata Steel Chess Facebook

Levon was asked if he was satisfied and responded, “Any time you win a game you can’t complain” and, “Generally winning a quick game is always a pleasure,” though he knows more than anyone what it means to play below his usual level just when the stakes are highest. He also had, perhaps for the first time in living memory, an interesting answer to the question of what he’d done on his rest day the day before. He visited the Armenian Embassy in Tbilisi and got some tips from Ambassador Yuri Vardanyan, a world record holding weight lifter and Olympic gold medalist. Levon wouldn’t reveal what the tips were, but it’s likely he’ll have some heavier weights to lift in the coming days!

You can watch Levon’s interview below:

Drawn before you know it

Vladimir Fedoseev is ready to hear the Russian national anthem at the closing ceremony... | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

The two underdogs in the second half of the bracket, Richard Rapport and Vladimir Fedoseev, both had the white pieces and didn’t hang around. Rapport-Ding Liren was drawn in 11 moves in a position where if anyone was better it was Black, while Fedoseev-So ended after 19 moves of a Petroff Defence that went the way such games used to go until players started castling on opposite wings and playing for mating attacks. The young underdogs may feel their chances increase in rapid chess, though to get there they have to survive with Black on Saturday.

Richard Rapport didn't have too much to ponder during his 11-move draw | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

Wesley So is one more draw away from dropping below Kramnik in the race to qualify for the Candidates Tournament by rating, but he won't care if he can progress in the tournament | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

The one draw that certainly wasn’t a formality was Peter Svidler’s clash with Maxime Vachier-Lagrave. As early as move 1 it seems there was a surprise, since according to our database meeting 1.c4 with 1…c5 was something Maxime had last done in 2002, when he was 11 or 12 years old.  

Svidler was close to taking a hugely important lead over MVL | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

Peter took 3 minutes to reply 2.Nf3 and after 2…Nf6 3.Nc3 d5 the players went for a strange and fashionable line where White loses the right to castle on move 7. The position reached after 11.Nb5 had actually been played by Svidler before against Ian Nepomniachtchi in the 2014 Russian Championship. Nepo took on b5, while MVL’s 11…Be6 looks to have been a novelty:

It’s not clear how good it was, or if Maxime followed up well (15…b5!?) since when queens were exchanged Black seemed dangerously close to being strategically lost:

White had the simple plan of targeting the c5-pawn with Nd2-b3 and possibly Rhc1 after Ke2, though after 22…Be7 in many lines Black picks up the h-pawn in exchange for the c-pawn. 

Not a walk in the park for French no. 1 Maxime Vachier-Lagrave | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

Maxime also went for counterplay by pushing his a-pawn, and in general it seemed he always had enough tricks. For instance, from a distance you might think 33.Bc5 was a winning pin:

But Maxime replied 33…Nb5!, when 34.Bxe7 would lose to the fork 34…Nd4+. True, after 34.Ke3! Black still had questions to answer, but MVL was up to it and a draw was agreed on move 41. We asked Peter if he felt he'd had a real chance to win:

Yes, it definitely felt that way, but apparently the machine holds it, or a close approximation of that, so less sad than I was immediately afterwards.

The final stages of the World Cup are familiar territory for Peter Svidler | photo: Anastasia Karlovich, official website

After that relative calm, Saturday is likely to be much more interesting. Ivanchuk must try and beat Aronian, all the players will have the looming prospect of being knocked out, and favourites MVL, So and Ding Liren will have their one chance to assert their dominance with the white pieces and spare themselves tiebreaks. Four places in the semi-finals await!

Catch all the action here on chess24 from 13:00 CEST onwards! You can also follow the games in our free mobile apps:


See more:

Sort by Date Descending Date Descending Date Ascending Most Liked Receive updates

Comments 9

Guest 12100972327
Join chess24
  • Free, Quick & Easy

  • Be the first to comment!


Create your free account now to get started!

By clicking ‘Register’ you agree to our terms and conditions and confirm you have read our privacy policy, including the section on the use of cookies.

Lost your password? We'll send you a link to reset it!

After submitting this form you'll receive an email with the reset password link. If you still can't access your account please contact our customer service.

Which features would you like to enable?

We respect your privacy and data protection guidelines. Some components of our site require cookies or local storage that handles personal information.

Show Options

Hide Options