Magnus Carlsen took an 11-minute think on move 2 on his way to a sparkling win over Maxime Vachier-Lagrave. That took the Norwegian into the Shamkir Chess lead after Wesley So was on the wrong end of a Vishy Anand masterpiece in his first game against the former World Champion. Another former Champion, Vladimir Kramnik, lost after six hours of torture from Shakhriyar Mamedyarov, while Anish Giri escaped from the clutches of Fabiano Caruana. What a day!
Just when it had seemed Wesley So might run away with the Gashimov Memorial in Shamkir he instead ran into some brilliant preparation from Vishy Anand, who said he’d been shown the idea by his second the day before.
IM David Martinez looks at the opening blow and the near flawless conversion that followed:
After Carlsen beat Anand in two World Championship matches there were some people who thought that facing Vishy was a walk in the park - that it didn't mean much to beat him and that avoiding his theoretical preparation was almost trivial. Well, games like this make you realise just how impressive Magnus' feat really was. I suspect So returned to his room this evening thinking, "wow, this guy is tough!"
1. e4 e5 2. ♘f3 ♘c6 3. ♗b5 a6 4. ♗a4 ♘f6 5. O-O ♗e7 6. d3 I could explain various things about the Ruy Lopez, but since there's a 3-hour video series about this by Peter Svidler (of whom more later in this report) what could I possibly add?
10. ♘g5 A beautiful move with the idea of sacrificing the knight after h6 by playing f4. The game between Caruana and So went:
10. a4 b4 11. ♘d5 ♘xd5 12. ♗xd5 c6 13. ♗b3 ♘d7 14. d4 a5 15. dxe5 dxe5 16. ♕e2 ♕c7 17. ♗e3 c5 18. ♗c4 ♘b6 19. ♗b5 f5 20. exf5 ♗xf5 21. c3 bxc3 22. bxc3 ♔h8 23. ♘d2 ♘d5 24. ♖ac1 ♖ad8 25. ♘c4 ♗f6 26. f3 ♘f4 27. ♗xf4 exf4 28. ♘d2 c4 29. ♘e4 ♖d3 30. ♘xf6 ♕b6+ 31. ♕f2 1/2-1/2 (31) Caruana,F (2820)-So,W (2762) Wijk aan Zee 2015
10... ♘c6 So decides to return the knight since he sees Anand is going to launch an attack on the kingside. His idea is to place it on d4, where apart from having a good outpost it will also help support a move like Be6. As we'll see in the game, it's normal that Vishy plays Ne2 in order to eliminate the knight, meaning So manages to exchange off a pair of pieces... That's the kind of small mercy to be grateful for when a heavy attack is looming!
10... h6 would be met by 11. f4! I think to properly analyse this line it would be necessary to postpone this article by a few weeks, so I'll instead try to take a brief look at some of the options in the full realisation that despite the best engine and will in the world the truth will remain distant. 11... hxg5 (11... exf4 would already be a concession since White can return to f3, or perhaps play more creatively by retreating to h3 or even sacrificing on f7.) 12. fxg5 White is threatening the knight, but also wants to play g6 and Qh5, so that the knight's options are reduced to a single one: 12... ♘g4 This is the only move that cuts off the path for the white queen. Now the "crude" 13. h3 would regain the knight, but then Black can take on g5 and it will be more or less equal. The obvious move is 13. g6 and since it's at least uncomfortable to have a pawn on f7 so soon in the game Black would have to play the magnificent 13... d5! threatening Bc5+ followed by Qh4. 14. d4! And now it's White who cuts off the path for the black bishop - what a position! Of course So realised that entering all this without analysis was very dangerous - and he was right! After some reflexion Stockfish spits out the following line: (14. ♗xd5 , as we explained, is impossible due to 14... ♗c5+ 15. ♔h1 ♕h4 16. h3 ♕g3 and in honour of Lawrence Trent I'm going to go all the way to mate: 17. hxg4 ♕h4# ) 14... ♘c6 A hard move to make. With enormous tension in the centre, everything hanging and various threats, Black develops the knight in order to take on d4.. . It's a good job the machine doesn't get nervous, since the lines that follow are mayhem:
a) 15. ♘xd5 is also possible, and after 15... ♘xd4 16. ♘xe7+ ♕xe7 17. ♗xf7+ Black has to choose between 17... ♖xf7 or (17... ♔h8 ) 18. gxf7+ ♔f8 and in both cases the position remains incredibly confusing.
b) 15. gxf7+ ♔h7‼ A great move! We'll see the reason for it in the line with 16. h3. 16. ♖f5! One for the crowd! The rook can't be captured, though it's not exactly obvious why, except for engines. (16. h3 looks very good, but after 16... ♘xd4 17. hxg4 ♘xb3 18. g5 Black has the brilliant 18... ♔g6! preventing the queen from coming to h5 and - look out! - Bc5+ and Rh8! are in the air. Truly wild!)
b2) 16... ♘h6 17. ♗xh6 gxh6 18. ♗xd5 and although White has three pawns for the piece and you can't exactly say the black king is safe, the machine thinks Black is doing well... Is it right? Perhaps! Would Anand have gone for this line? It's hard to say. Perhaps if So had responded quickly (a sign he'd analysed it) then he would have chosen 15. Nxd5, but if So was thinking over the board Anand might have chosen this, knowing that Black has to resolve difficult practical problems... In any case, it would have been a riot!
11. ♗a2 Anticipating the arrival of the knight on d4.
11... h6 12. f4 would again be absolute chaos. The fact that the black knight is already on c6 might favour Black, although as we've seen, in some lines the bishop comes to d5, so once again nothing is clear!
14... exf4 could once again be met calmly with 15. ♘f3 and although the engine shows 15... g5 with an edge for Black, this time I don't believe it! White can prepare to break open the black kingside and I know which side I'd rather be on.
16... ♘h6 which, frankly, looks horrible! But once again, the machines (and in such positions there's not much room for human opinion) find a defence from another planet. 17. ♗xh6 gxh6 18. ♖xf7 ♖xf7 19. ♖f1 Black's going to get mated in a few moves, isn't he? Just watch how Stockfish defends - with only moves. (19. ♕f2 ♗f6 20. gxf7+ ♔f8 21. ♖f1 ♗g7 seems to hold things together.) 19... ♔g7! 20. ♖xf7+ ♔xg6! 21. ♕f3 h5‼ Threatening Bg4, since it frees up the h6-square for the king. It's curious to note that after 22. h3 Stockfish demostrates a great sense of humour by proposing 22... h4 , preventing Qg3, and White has nothing better than to take a perpetual check. What a defence!
17. h3 A way has to be found to get the queen to h5.
19. ♕h5 Threatening Bxf7, so once again Black has an only move.
21. g4 Pouring more fuel on the fire! There's no way to prevent g5, so White regains the piece.
22. g5 immediately would have been more effective since, as we'll see, the move in the game gives So a chance to put up tough resistance.
25. gxh6 ♖xf1+ 26. ♔xf1 ♕f8+ 27. ♔e2 Vishy felt it was crucial that the king makes it over onto the queenside, above all in order to avoid perpetual checks, but also to have a chance to invade on the dark squares.
27... gxh6 28. ♕g4! ♕f6 29. h4! The h-pawn shores up its colleague on g6. Although there's material equality on the board Black can barely move. Nevertheless, the move So chooses makes White's task easier.
29... d5? I think there was very little So could have done against the incredible play of Anand in this game, and though there were some other occasions when he could have played different moves this is the only one that deserves any criticism in human terms. The idea of putting the pawn on d4 allowed Vishy to break through and achieve a clear-cut victory, but instead
29... a5 with the idea of following up 30. b4 with 30... a4 would greatly have complicated White's task. 31. h5 c5! The key to Black's defence. The idea is that if the white queen tries to enter on the queenside the black queen will be in time to take on h5 and g6. The ending would still be very complicated after a move like 32. c4! leading to an extremely exciting position where I was unable to find a way for White to win. It's worth taking a look at some of the lines, since they're totally surreal! 32... cxb4 33. cxb5 b3 34. b6 b2 35. ♕g1 Black's b-pawn is stopped so the White b-pawn will decide matters... or will it? 35... ♕g5! 36. b7! ♕xh5+ (36... ♕xg1 is impossible due to 37. b8Q+ ♔g7 38. ♕c7+ ♔f6 39. ♕d8+ and Black gets mated.) 37. ♔d2 ♕h2+! What a resource! 38. ♕xh2 b1Q 39. ♕xh6 ♕b2+! An essential nuance. (39... ♕xb7 can't be played since the pawn ending is lost. 40. ♕h7+ ♕xh7 41. gxh7+ ♔xh7 42. ♔c3 ) 40. ♔e3 (40. ♔d1 ♕xb7 is now possible since the white king is badly placed for the pawn ending.) 40... ♕c1+! (40... ♕xb7 would in this case be met by 41. g7 ♕xg7 42. ♕xe6+ and the ending should be lost.) 41. ♔e2 ♕xh6 42. b8Q+ ♔g7 43. ♕xd6 The position seems almost lost for Black but the machine finds a brilliant defence: 43... ♕h2+ 44. ♔d1 ♕b2! 45. ♕d7+ ♔h6! 46. ♕xa4 ♕b1+ And Black manages to trap the white king. Not bad, right?
31... ♔g7 32. ♕f3 ♕e7 33. ♔d1 ♔g8 34. ♕f2 ♔g7 35. c3! dxc3 36. ♔c2 ♕c7 37. ♕c5 ♔g8 38. ♕e3 a5 39. ♕h3 axb4 40. ♕xe6+ ♔f8 41. axb4 ♕a7 42. ♔xc3 ♕a3+ 43. ♔c2 ♕a4+ 44. ♕b3 ♕a7 45. d4 A pretty final break in order to allow the white king to come to d3. So resigned. A magnificent attacking game by Vishy Anand, who showed off some of his greatest strengths: deep and original preparation and great precision in dynamic play. A masterpiece!
Afterwards Wesley So didn’t feel he’d been overawed but had simply encountered his opponent on a very good day:
Vishy played really well today and completely outplayed me. It doesn’t really matter who you’re playing… my opponent made lots of accurate moves today and it’s an uncomfortable position.
Vishy was also happy, and it’s credit to So’s great run that beating him means something:
Today was a very nice win against the tournament leader, who’s just been dominating.
When the players were asked the inevitable question about playing football on the rest day Vishy’s response...
(the reference, in case you missed it!)
...was soon picked up by the recovering Peter himself:
You can watch the players discussing the game below:
That game suddenly made it possible for Magnus Carlsen to take the lead, and it was the kind of chance he doesn’t often turn down.
Maxime Vachier-Lagrave had gone on record as regretting being unable to play any interesting chess in Shamkir so far since he kept playing or walking into heavy theoretical lines. Well, at least that all changed in Round 5!
1.Nf3 Nf6 2.g3 was a sure-fire way of stopping any Grünfelds, and then after 2…b5 took Maxime over 5 minutes Magnus took 11 minutes to decide on 3.Bg2 Bg7 and now another 3 minutes for 4.Na3:
Quite a picturesque position, and one that Maxime spent 18 minutes contemplating before choosing 4…a6, which was hit by 5.c4 – and another pause for thought. The dance continued, with the players summing it up on Twitter:
The move that stopped all the fun, for one of the players,
Gradually the truth dawned on Maxime that this wasn’t blundering a pawn but an “extremely strong” move:
I took a lot of time to understand what was the point and then I understood it wasn’t going to be easy today.
Maxime saw nothing better than going down the rabbit hole with 14…Nxd5 15.Bh6! gxh6 16.Qg4+ Bg5 17.cxd5, when his horrible kingside structure promised nothing good. What followed was another masterclass, which is best simply played through on our broadcast (where you can try alternative moves and even get computer analysis of them), with the additional resource of a very entertaining post-game press conference:
As you can see, Maxime knew he’d witnessed something special afterwards, even if it wasn’t all visible at a glance:
At first maybe I was confused but it’s clear that Magnus played extremely well today. This idea is maybe not terribly difficult to see, but it doesn’t really come obviously to the mind. Some of the moves… as usual with Carlsen it always looks very easy when it’s played, but it’s not so easy to notice.
Carlsen was of course happy:
To play interesting chess and also to win on one day - you can’t have it better than that!
Even in press conferences he has an ability to surprise you. A question on the big, heavy chess pieces used in Shamkir reminded us that his success isn't only about sporting qualities and will to win:
It gives more of a feeling of harmony during the game - I think for many chess players harmony is very important.
We’re getting to witness an artist at work.
The last time these players met for a classical game it was a gut-wrenching encounter for Shakhriyar Mamedyarov. He’d won two of his last three games in the 2014 Candidates Tournament in Khanty-Mansiysk, and after a middlegame where Kramnik was on top he seized the initiative and was close to winning – only to throw away the win with a move made in 8 seconds in no time trouble and follow it up by a second that condemned him to certain defeat.
We captured the action in our report, which included the following photograph, caption and quote from the press conference:
I think I did very well to find a win and kept playing – and I thought this was the last move and he’ll resign. So I played it very quickly. Such a blunder…
That game was on Shakhriyar’s mind today when he was asked about Vladimir failing to appear for the post-game press conference. Although Mamedyarov could understand it, and his opponent was a World Champion, he pointed out he'd faced the press back then.
The game itself was Mamedyarov’s first ever classical victory over Kramnik and another game full of fine ideas, which became exciting after the Azeri player sacrificed a pawn on move 18 and then played the subtle 24.a3! six moves later:
He explained afterwards that other options had looked drawish, but now he suddenly gets play on the a2-g8 diagonal. It helped matters that Kramnik was slipping into time trouble and had little time to think when 31.Nxb6! appeared on the board:
Kramnik spent under a minute choosing 31…axb6?!, when after 32.Qb3! Be6 (the threat was mate-in-1) 33.Qxe6 Qxe6 34.Bxe6 Mamedyarov had won a pawn, which he eventually managed to convert into a win after another 40 or so moves. The computers claim 31…Qxd6 is equal here, though it’s easy to see why Kramnik would fear the plan Mamedyarov pointed out in the post-game press conference: 32.Na4 Ra5 33.Rc1!, exploiting the fact that 31…Rxa4? runs into 32.Qb3! (again that mate-in-one threat). It would have been very tough to stay afloat in time trouble, though Kramnik might have preferred a quick death to what befell him!
Watch the post-game press conference, which Mamedyarov was kind enough to conduct almost entirely in English!
That only leaves the two draws, one of which, the 50-move encounter between strugglers Rauf Mamedov and Michael Adams, can safely be passed over in silence. It was a hard-fought but balanced encounter, with the most interesting moment perhaps coming afterwards when Mamedov said he’d always been a great fan of Michael’s and would have been rooting for him if he wasn’t playing.
And then there are the two contenders for the chess throne, Fabiano Caruana and Anish Giri. Caruana unleashed a “very interesting” new idea on move 13, and it did the trick – by move 19, after an oversight, Giri was all but busted:
He admitted his thoughts had turned to his next game with Carlsen, but took a philosophical approach:
I decided I’m probably lost and I left it to Caruana to find out how.
Fabiano’s problem was that he thought he did find a win with a line concluding with 28.Qa1:
The pin on the d-file looks fatal, and it would be, apart from the only move he’d missed 28…Re8!, and the rook can come to e7 and hold Black’s shaky structure together. It wasn’t only that, though, since Giri noted:
There was no transitional phase. White was winning and then it was already equal.
In fact relief at surviving was soon replaced by euphoria, since Giri thought he was going to go on and win, but although Caruana was annoyed at letting a “clean win” slip from his grasp he buckled down and held the draw.
The press conference was fun, with Giri perhaps taking a sneaky swing at his Round 6 opponent – and a man he has a +1 score against – Magnus Carlsen:
I have some nice opponents, some “clients” of mine to come, so I’m feeling optimistic!
Watch it here:
Before Round 6, though, the Gods have placed the rest day, and it’ll include the now traditional game of football. In 2014 that was mainly noteworthy for Magnus managing to almost kill the Chief Arbiter. Caruana had that incident in mind when he revealed he’d be playing:
I’m just wondering who he’s going to kick tomorrow.
Elmira Mirzoeva asked if he was going to be on Magnus’ team, but Anish burst in with:
With Magnus it doesn’t matter!
Back in the tournament, Magnus Carlsen has now taken the lead with four rounds to go, with only Vishy Anand also remaining unbeaten:
Assuming the players survive the football on Thursday we’ll have not only Giri-Carlsen, but Kramnik-Caruana! Don’t miss all the games live here on chess24 from 12:00 CEST. You can also watch on our free mobile apps:
We respect your privacy and data protection guidelines. Some components of our site require cookies or local storage that handles personal information.