Latest news

Features Feb 25, 2016 | 11:50 PMby GM Pepe Cuenca

Quantum Chess: A new variant helps you understand physics

This evening chess24's Miss Strategy, IM Anna Rudolf, took part in a special match playing a new chess variant dubbed Quantum Chess. She faced the creator of game, Chris Cantwell, a graduate student at the University of Southern California. Replay the full show, and learn a thing or two about quantum physics along the way!

In 2013 I was studying for a Masters at the Polytechnic University of Gdansk (Poland). During a course on nanotechnology I was asked to introduce some applications of quantum mechanics, and indeed that's where I first found out that there were different forms of "quantum" chess.

Taking advantage of this event organized by chess24 in collaboration with, I decided to do an article trying to explain some concepts of quantum physics that are used in this new type of game such as:

  1. Schrödinger state
  2. Entanglement

Before getting caught up in these more complicated concepts, I want to talk a little about the potential usefulness of this new type of game and the rules that exist for it:

Human intelligence vs artificial intelligence

Many games, especially chess, have always been considered as a valid test to see if a computer can show some form of intelligence. Computers use "brute force" or massive information processing in parallel where the game is modeled as a tree. By contrast, humans use reason and intuition.

Humans lost the battle some time ago against chess computers, with the turning point being the victory of Deep Blue against Garry Kasparov in May 1997.

A scene from the 6-game match in which IBM's Deep Blue emerged the winner | photo:

It is undeniable that the scope of chess is immense, but it is also true that by adding a new simple rule, an infinite world of new possibilities opens (for instance, chess960 , a.k.a. Fischer-random chess).

Already in 2010 Dr. Selim Akl, of the Queen's University in Ontario, Canada, noted in a scientific article that one of the advantages of quantum chess is that it restores (at least for a while) the balance between humans and computers, thanks to concepts such as superposition, uncertainty, interference, entanglement, etc.

Chris Cantwell's version of Quantum Chess

An early prototype screen of Chris Cantwell's chess variant

Taking a look at the rules laid out in Chris's recent blog on quantum chess we can observe the following:

All pieces except the pawns can make either a normal move or a quantum move. With a quantum move, the piece is placed in a "superposition" with two possible outcomes: a 50% probability that it can make up to two consecutive movements and the other 50% probability that will not move at all (i.e. if you decide to move your king from e8 to e7, you do not know if it will actually end up on e8 or e7).

Chris Cantwell, creator of "Quantum Chess"

This concept allows pieces to become intertwined (or entangled). Having pieces in superposition can lead to situations where a square may be occupied by two different pieces at the same time. When this occurs a measurement is performed to determine which piece ends up on the square in question.

Well it has come time to mess with physics! We will try to explain, in simple terms, what is meant by superposition and entanglement concepts from the point of view of quantum mechanics.

If you don't feel like getting too far "into the weeds", now would be a good time to check out the awesome video starring actor Paul Rudd and renowned physicist Dr. Stephen Hawking and narrated by Keanu Reeves that was made in support of a Kickstarter project to raise funds for the development of the game:

Quantum Mechanics

When we speak of the universe, we think of galaxies, stars and planets that we can see with telescopes thousands of kilometers or light years away. We think of bodies moving according to the laws of gravity. However, there is "another universe": an invisible world that rules over everything we see. This is a microscopic world — not the size of a star, but that of an atom — where laws are much less intuitive than in our more familiar macroscopic world.

At this scale matter behaves so differently that scientists have developed a completely new theory to explain what happens. In "quantum theory", subatomic particles do some pretty strange things. They are invisible, they can pass through solid objects, and they can be in several places at a time. The latter seems the stuff of science fiction, and yet it seems to be true in the quantum world.

Quantum superposition / Schrödinger's state

The Schrodinger equation describes the evolution over time of a massive subatomic particle with a non-relativistic wave nature.

And you thought the Najdorf Defence was hard!

At this point you will probably be saying to yourself, "Pepe, stop speaking in Greek and giving me a headache." Obviously we are not going to get into detail, but I would like to note that interest in this field began to emerge in the early twentieth century when it was found that light had a wave-particle duality. The quantum superposition occurs when an object "has simultaneously" two or more values of an observable quantity. The so-called "Copenhagen interpretation" expresses this with the following equation:

Taken from "On the importance of being quantum" by Selim Akl, 2010

Here alpha and beta are the odds that the Nl and Rr statements are presented. To make this easier to understand, we will explain the experiment called Schrödinger's cat or paradox.

Imagine that we have a box with a cat and some quantity of gunpowder that will explode with 50% probability in the next minute. Until we look inside, we do not know if the cat is dead or alive (see figure 1).

Figure 2: Minutephysics YouTube channel

If we repeat the experiment many times with different cats, etc., we can see that in half times the cat survives and the other half he dies (see figure 2).

The interpretation of quantum mechanics says that before we take a look inside, the cat is in a superposition, that is, dead and alive at the same time (see figure 3). Our act of looking at nature actually forces one or the other outcome (literally curiosity killed the cat).

Figure 3: Minutephysics YouTube Channel

Figure 4: Minutephysics YouTube Channel

The reality is that we are in the same situation as the cat (see figure 4): the cat lives and we see it safe and sound, or dies and we find him so.

So the question is: who observes us to force nature to collapse into one reality?

Well, we will not solve that one here, because this is one of the issues not yet resolved in all of quantum physics.

For more, the whole thought experiment is very well explained in this video:

Quantum entanglement

The key to understanding all quantum phenomena is a process called quantum entanglement and now scientists are very interested in this amazing discovery for both civilian and military purposes.

In quantum mechanics, what happens to a particle that is in some position, A, can instantly affect a particle in position B — and position B could be billions of light years away from A.

Here is the process: when two subatomic particles interact, they can "intertwine", which means that the position or other properties go hand in hand. If you measure any property in one particle, that instantly determines the value in the other particle.

Representation of two subatomic particles intertwined | Image: stargazer YouTube channel

That means for example that if a scientist finds a particle "intertwined" and forces it to rotate in a clockwise direction, the other particle will begin to do the same.

This statement is very interesting because what it indicates, or at least suggests, is that information has traveled faster than the speed of light from one particle to the other. This I do not understand nor does anyone! Einstein called it "spooky action at a distance".

Well folks, I hope you liked this not so conventional bit of news on our website, and if you want to learn a little more about the idea of quantum chess by all means watch Anna Rudolf's show. The 2-game match ended in a 1-1 tie!

GM Jose Cuenca

Jose "Pepe" Cuenca is a grandmaster and civil engineer. Currently he combines chess competition with his work as a researcher at the University of Hamburg and work with chess24.

Sort by Date Descending Date Descending Date Ascending Most Liked Receive updates

Comments 17

Guest 4678666484
Join chess24
  • Free, Quick & Easy

  • Be the first to comment!


Create your free account now to get started!

I am aged 16 or older.

By clicking ‘Register’ you agree to our terms and conditions and confirm you have read our privacy policy, including the section on the use of cookies.

Lost your password? We'll send you a link to reset it!

After submitting this form you'll receive an email with the reset password link. If you still can't access your account please contact our customer service.

Data Consent Details

We respect your privacy and data protection guidelines.

Using chess24 requires the storage of some personal data, as set out below. You can find additional information in our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, Disclaimer and Terms of Website Use. Please note that your data settings can be changed at any time by clicking on the Data Settings link in the footer at the bottom of our website.

data details

Necessary Data

Some data is technically necessary to be able to visit the page at all. A so-called cookie stores identifiers that make it possible to respond to your individual requests. It contains a session ID - a unique, anonymous user ID combined with an authentication identifier (user_data). A security identifier (csrf) is also stored to prevent a particular type of online attack. All of these fields are alpha-numeric, with almost no relation to your real identity. The only exception is that we monitor some requests with the IP address that you are currently using, so that we are able to detect malicious use or system defects. Additionally, a technical field is stored (singletab) to ensure that some interactions are only processed in the browser tab that is currently active. For example, a new chess game will not be opened in all your current tabs. We use your local storage to save the difference between your local clock and our server time (serverUserTimeOffset), so that we are able to display the date and time of events correctly for you. You can also enable more data fields, as described in the other sections. Your personal decision on which data storage to enable is also stored as necessary information (consent).

Settings Data

We offer a range of personal settings for your convenience. Options include which opponents you prefer to be paired against, your preferred chessboard and pieces, the board size, the volume setting of the video player, your preferred language, whether to show chat or chess notation, and more. You can use our web page without storing this data, but if you would like to have your individual settings remembered we recommend enabling this feature. For logged-in registered users this setting is mandatory to store information about your privacy settings, users you have blocked and your friendship settings. As a registered user we also store your data consent in these settings.

Social Media Data

We embed a Twitter feed showing activity for the hashtag #c24live and also make it possible to share content in social networks such as Facebook, Twitter and Google+. If you enable this option social networks are able to store data in your cookies or local storage for the purpose of these features.

Statistics Data

We would like to measure how our page is used with Google Analytics, so that we can decide which features to implement next and how to optimize our user experience. If you enable this feature Google will store your device identifiers and we will send tracking events (such as page requests) to Google Analytics. These have no direct relationship to your person except for the IP address currently being used.

Marketing Data

To help cover the cost of free services we would like to show you advertisements from our partner networks. Members of these networks store data on the banners shown to you and try to deliver ads that are relevant. If you choose not to allow this kind of data we have to show more anonymous advertisements and will be more limited in the free services we can offer.

Other Data

For registered users we store additional information such as profile data, chess games played, your chess analysis sessions, forum posts, chat and messages, your friends and blocked users, and items and subscriptions you have purchased. You can find this information in your personal profile. A free registration is not required to use this application. If you decide to contact the support team a ticket is created with information that includes your name and email address so that we can respond to your concern. This data is processed in the external service Zendesk. If you subscribe to a newsletter or are registered we would like to send you occasional updates via email. You can unsubscribe from newsletters and as a registered user you can apply several mail settings to control how your email address is used. For newsletters we transfer your email address and username to the external service MailChimp. If you buy content or subscriptions on chess24 we work with the payment service provider Adyen, which collects your payment data and processes information about the payment such as fraud protection data.