Reports Apr 30, 2016 | 2:03 PMby Colin McGourty

Nakamura wins Kasparov show: Ultimate Blitz Day 2

Hikaru Nakamura scored 6/9 on Day 2 of the Ultimate Blitz Challenge in St. Louis to win the $20,000 first prize by a full point. Second went to Wesley So, who played the tournament’s instant classic to beat Garry Kasparov in the opening round. The chess legend finished half a point back in third place, but proved he still has what it takes to compete with the best, winning the mini-matches against Nakamura and Caruana. The US Champion finished in a distant fourth place.

Garry Kasparov won the individual 6-game battle against Hikaru Nakamura, but it was the US player who picked up the $20,000 first prize | photo: Lennart Ootes, St. Louis Chess Club 

Day 2 of the Ultimate Blitz Challenge began in sensational style with a Morphy-like win for Wesley So over Garry Kasparov, before Hikaru Nakamura took over the proceedings to lead by two points with two rounds to go. It looked like the rest might be a formality, but then Nakamura suffered his first loss of the day – to Garry Kasparov – to set up a final-round decider with Wesley So. A draw was ultimately enough for Nakamura, but it meant we had intrigue from start to finish. You can rewatch the whole show below:

Replay all 36 games from the tournament by clicking on a result below:

Let’s look at how the final day went for the players, in reverse order:

Fabiano Caruana, 4th place, 5.5/18

Fabiano Caruana was in supreme form in the US Championship, but was made to look very ordinary in blitz | photo: Lennart Ootes, St. Louis Chess Club

Caruana's Day 2 results

Fabiano Caruana leaves St. Louis a winner – the world no. 2 and the US Chess Champion – but he also left us with a familiar puzzle. How is it that such a phenomenally good player is so poor (relatively speaking!) at blitz? His rating is a mere 2665, making him the world no. 85 in the format, with Veselin Topalov almost the only other elite player whose classical results are so different from those in speed chess. His victory over Nakamura in last year’s Showdown in St. Louis looks like an anomaly.

This year’s Ultimate Blitz wasn’t rated, but it wouldn’t have helped his cause. In the final 12 games Fabiano lost 9, drew 2 and had only a single win over Kasparov to show for his endeavour. As Nakamura put it:

There was one player who really didn’t play well today and that was Fabiano. Because of that several of us were able to rack up a lot of points - that’s what made the difference.

Caruana was making no excuses and simply answered “everything!” when asked what had gone wrong:

It can also happen in classical chess, but in blitz it happens so much more suddenly and it’s really hard to stop it. The games just come one after another. If you’re not playing well it’s very easy to lose a bunch in a row.

Life still remains good for Fabi, though. He recently bought a house in St. Louis and was profiled in the New Yorker:

When America most cared about chess, the drama was largely symbolic: America against the Soviets. Caruana was born long after chess’s great geopolitical showdown, and all he can do, he said, is try to win. “It’s actually a pretty chill life,” he explained. “I study maybe three or four hours a day, if I’m motivated. I like to play basketball—which I’m awful at—go swimming, ride my bike. When I came back from the Candidates Cup [sic], I spent most of my days at the pool.”

“I think I will be world champion someday,” he continued. “I don’t know if that sounded very convincing.” Caruana described Carlsen as “an extremely well-rounded player,” but pointed out that he still has weaknesses. “When the position gets out of control, he can be out-calculated. I’ve out-calculated him in the past,” he said. “If he feels uncomfortable, he can lose confidence and strength. But it’s hard to get him in those situations. I do have weaknesses, too, which I won’t reveal.”

It’s probably not a closely-guarded secret that for now blitz chess is a weakness of Fabiano’s, and one that might prove a liability at every stage up to and including a World Championship match.

Garry Kasparov, 3rd place, 9.5/18

If there was one man they'd all come to see, it was Garry Kasparov | photo: Lennart Ootes, St. Louis Chess Club

Kasparov's Day 2 results

After a crushing loss in the first game of the final day – of which more later – it seemed the fairy tale might have ended for Kasparov. Were we about to see a return to harsh reality, where the 53-year-old retiree would get knocked about by some of the hungriest stars of the new generation? The answer was a resounding no! Garry went on to lose only one more game and kept up the fight for the top places.

In the first two games against Nakamura they traded missed winning chances, while in the third Nakamura succumbed after getting into trouble in the opening and making what Kasparov called the “unexplainable” decision to give up a piece on move 13.

Nakamura has met his body-language match, with Kasparov demonstrating exactly what he thinks of the piece sac/blunder | photo: Lennart Ootes, St. Louis Chess Club

That meant Garry went into the last game against Caruana with a chance of second place. We said in our previous report that although Kasparov had won some fine games in the Ultimate Blitz none of them had been in the rampaging sacrificial style we’re most familiar with. That changed against Fabiano! First, though, there was a trip down memory lane for Kasparov:

Sometimes old memories are revived. I played this move 9…Bf5 against the British player Webb in the first round of the European Team Championship in 1980, and it was my first actual game for the Soviet national squad. I was the second reserve. He played 10.d4 e4 and I think he played 11.Ng5 Re8 and I was very proud with this move Bf5 because it allowed me to meet d4 with e4. I won a very nice game. His knight was rotten.

Kasparov was, of course, absolutely right, as you can see from our broadcast. Note the new searchable database, that made it possible, for instance, to watch Kasparov’s games live while almost instantly showing any games he’d previously played in the same positions!

Instead of 11.Ng5 Caruana went for 11.Ne1, but it didn’t work out any better, as Garry explains:

The way Caruana played it was so easy for Black because I could build my momentum there and it reminded me of the last game I played with Nigel here, because it’s also having all the pieces there. It was easy, but still, I enjoyed it! I liked the moment when I could sacrifice on g4 just to keep all the pawns out of the board and then just to have the final attack. The Rh8, Kg8, Bf8 was nice. A nice finish!

You can replay the game here, but two snapshots:

Winter is coming!

The final position

Nigel Short himself was watching, from a safe distance:

Overall Kasparov was satisfied:

I’m quite happy. I won two micro-matches, I ended plus one, so I did better than many expected… Yesterday I missed my chance. Just not blundering these two knights – scoring probably a point and a half against So in these two games – that would be a very different tournament.

He won $10,000, but is giving that away to support the US chess team at the Olympiad. Why?

I’m an amateur, I’m not a professional player! So they were gracious, they wanted to play this event and I thought it would be nice if I make the donation. I hoped it would be a bigger donation!

The current contenders for the chess crown watch the former World Champion | photo: Lennart Ootes, St. Louis Chess Club 

The other players gave their verdict on Kasparov’s performance.

Hikaru Nakamura:

I think Garry’s preparation was quite good for this event. Obviously chess has changed and you can’t just win games out of the opening, but he did find ways to create positions where it was much easier for him to play than it was for us. When that happens in normal games it’s a challenge, but when it happens in blitz, where you don’t have a lot of time to figure it out, it becomes especially tricky. I thought Garry was quite good at that today. He probably should have finished in second, I think.

Hikaru would like to see Kasparov play again in future:

The main thing is it’s clear that he’s not done. He’s still quite competitive and I think if he’s competitive I don’t know why he shouldn’t play. Playing normal tournaments takes too much time and it’s a real grind, especially at his age, but still, he’s a competitive player and these exhibitions… I don’t see any reason why he shouldn’t. I think it’s very good for chess.

Nakamura also took to Twitter:

Wesley So:

I was kind of shocked when I lost my first two games in this tournament, because I didn’t realise simply how powerful my opponents were and I didn’t expect Garry to play the same exciting, energetic chess as he did before. He played extremely well and I was fortunate to save a lot of games against him.

Fabiano Caruana:

He’s still a very strong player. I don’t think that really came as a surprise to anyone. Especially at blitz he still has fantastic instincts. Those really go a long way. Opening preparation and knowledge of current opening trends and what’s happened for the past decade is much less relevant. He does occasionally blunder, he’s definitely a lot weaker than at his peak, but he’s still a very, very good player.

"Yes, yes, yes!" Kasparov's feelings on playing more chess in the immediate aftermath of beating Caruana and Nakamura in consecutive games | photo: Lennart Ootes, St. Louis Chess Club

Garry himself responded to the inevitable question of whether he would consider playing more chess:

Right now, being fresh after two straight victories against Nakamura and Caruana, I’m inclined to say yes, yes, yes! But remembering my emotions last night, this morning, I’m not so sure. I think I’ve proved that I could play against them, so it’s a lot of fun. Maybe, but if I take the challenge again I would probably do more serious preparation because you have so many things floating in your head at my age – family, you have other things, I have lectures, I have writings, I do a lot of stuff on Twitter and Facebook, the political appearances. Then you have to think about the Scotch, you have to think about other things! The problem is many positions are difficult for me to play because I don’t have the practice. They play some positions so often, like the Berlin or the classical Ruy Lopez or the Queen’s Gambit. I know how to play them, but in blitz it’s very difficult to take this challenge, because it’s all about instincts and they’re much better prepared for that. If it happens again I will probably look at some other ideas, but when I had my chance to attack and just sacrifice some material I did well!

Garry was straight back on Twitter after the event!

Wesley So, 2nd place, 10/18

So's Day 2 results

Wesley So almost single-handedly prevented Garry Kasparov from challenging for first place in the Ultimate Blitz, scoring 3 wins and 2 draws against the legend after losing to him in the first game of the tournament. 

Wesley So focuses before playing an all-time classic

He even managed to haunt Garry’s dreams:

It was a tough night actually, because I just couldn’t get rid of these horrors, these blunders. Actually the worst memory of yesterday was not a blunder but the way I played against Wesley, so it probably had a psychological impact on me, so that’s why I played so poorly against him today.

Kasparov has often been reluctant to credit his defeats to wonderful play from his opponents – his outrage over 15-year-old Teimour Radjabov receiving the beauty prize for defeating him with Black (the first person to do so in a rated game in 7 years) in Linares 2003 comes to mind – so we should balance the account by giving Yasser Seirawan’s assessment of So’s win in Round 10 of the Ultimate Blitz:

I will remain in awe of that blitz game for the rest of my life. I just thought watching that unfold was unbelievable. The dynamic aggression Wesley showed in that game, sacrificing one pawn, two pawns, the knight, the rook – it was just poetry!

The truth, of course, lay somewhere in between, but it was an awesome spectacle to see Wesley sacrifice three pawns in 15 moves to rip open Kasparov’s position. It was objectively lost already, but 18…b5 (belatedly “correcting” the mistake of playing 12…b6) just welcomed the final assault:

19.Ncxe5! fxe5 20.Bxb5 Rb8 21.Ba4! Qb7

22.Rxc6! Nxc6 23.Qe6+ Ne7 24.Bc5 Rc8 25.Bxe7

With mate-in-4 on the board Kasparov decided it was time to end the massacre (replay it in full here). Wesley So commented:

To do this against the immortal Garry Kasparov is just incredible!

Garry did give credit for how the game concluded:

He finished very, very nicely. It’s a beautiful game, but it reminded me of the games Morphy played with amateurs – I was an amateur in this game! It was a total disaster, but ok, it’s a nice game.

In the remaining games only losses to Nakamura held So back, but he still went into the final game knowing a win with the black pieces would force a playoff (a blitz playoff!):

If he could be criticised for one thing in the tournament it was for taking a draw at the end, but it was a position it would be almost impossible to win, and if he lost it would have cost him not so much money (he’d be $2,500 poorer after sharing 2nd-3rd place with Kasparov) but the bragging rights of finishing above the former World Champion.

Hikaru Nakamura, 1st place, 11/18

Magnus Carlsen commented on Day 1 of the Ultimate Blitz: "It didn’t seem that Hikaru & Wesley had the right sort of attitude. They didn’t seem to be really in it." Whatever the truth of that, on the second day Nakamura was always focussed and in control | photo: Lennart Ootes, St. Louis Chess Club

Hikaru confirmed his status as one of the best blitz players on the planet, first by rescuing a decent result on the first day and then by (almost) cruising to victory on the second. As he explained:

It’s just yesterday I was not seeing anything. Every game yesterday I was losing at some point, there’s no doubt about that. If you play one bad game, two, three, it can happen, but to be much worse to lost in every single one… I just wasn’t there yesterday, but today things went a lot better for me – pretty smooth, I would say.

He lost his only game when he was already leading by two points with two rounds to go. 

Nakamura's Day 2 results

The crucial moments, though, were against Wesley So. He managed to win a 4-rook ending against his main rival in Round 12 and then spotted a winning tactic in Round 15 (“I took advantage of the opportunities when they arose – today especially”):

27…Nxb4! That won a vital pawn, since 28.Nxb4? of course allows 28…Qd1 mate. Wesley described the shock of that move:

That was unfortunate. He played the same variation as he did yesterday in the Queen’s Gambit Declined and he had some improvement and some new ideas of a setup and then I simply became too passive and too comfortable in my position. I thought I had a solid position and then suddenly he took my pawn on b4.

After 28.Qxb4 Qxc2 Nakamura’s conversion was flawless, with the final move worthy of effectively winning the tournament:

39…Bd4! and the a-pawn queens.   

Nakamura was glad to end his St. Louis experience on a high, but was looking forward to a break from chess:

To not win something here would have been a little disappointing. I’m just happy that I was able to play well today. I feel like the last couple of days I’ve just been starting to lose it a little bit – just too much chess since February. It’s kind of the end of a long, long series of tournaments and I’m just happy that I was able to win today and now I can relax for a few months… I’ve been on the road since early January. It’s been a lot of chess, a lot of travelling, a lot of ups and downs, especially at the Candidates. I’m glad I can get a break!

So the final standings were as follows:

1Hikaru Nakamura278701½11½½01½½0101½1111.0
2Wesley So277310½00½0111½½0½11½110.0
3Garry Kasparov2812½10½½11000½½½½11019.5
4Fabiano Caruana2795010½001½00½0½½00105.5

Ultimate Blitz is over... | photo: Lennart Ootes, St. Louis Chess Club

Nakamura’s next event will be the Grand Chess Tour rapid and blitz tournament in Paris in early June, but we don’t have to wait so long for major chess action elsewhere. There’s the Italian Team Championship, the final weekend of the 4NCL, the Hasselbacken Open, the German Club Cup, the Batumi Women’s GP and the likes of Kramnik, Aronian and Svidler are heading to Sochi to play in the Russian Team Championship from tomorrow. Follow all the action on our Live Tournaments page!

See also:

Sort by Date Descending Date Descending Date Ascending Most Liked Receive updates

Comments 12

Guest 7521178176
Join chess24
  • Free, Quick & Easy

  • Be the first to comment!


Create your free account now to get started!

I am aged 16 or older.

By clicking ‘Register’ you agree to our terms and conditions and confirm you have read our privacy policy, including the section on the use of cookies.

Lost your password? We'll send you a link to reset it!

After submitting this form you'll receive an email with the reset password link. If you still can't access your account please contact our customer service.

Which features would you like to enable?

We respect your privacy and data protection guidelines. Some components of our site require cookies or local storage that handles personal information.

Show Options

Hide Options