General Sep 12, 2014 | 3:41 PMby Colin McGourty

Caruana tops Grand Prix line-up

If the Sinquefield Cup had taken place a couple of weeks earlier Fabiano Caruana might have decided he could rely on his rating alone to get him a place in the next Candidates Tournament, but as it is he’s the top seed for the 2014/15 Grand Prix. Big guns such as Carlsen, Anand, Aronian and Kramnik have dropped out, but the line-up remains impressive. We take a look at some of the storylines behind the latest list of names.

Caruana bucked the trend by still playing Opens while already a super-grandmaster, now he's doing it again by playing the Grand Prix despite his ski-high rating

Since the new Grand Prix series was first announced the line-up has undergone a complete overhaul. Five players have dropped out to be replaced with:  the three players on the reserve list – Sergey Karjakin, Boris Gelfand and Shakhriyar Mamedyarov, the four nominees of the host cities (rebranded as “AGON nominees”) – Teimour Radjabov (Baku), Rustam Kasimdzhanov (Tashkent), Ehsan Ghaem Maghami (Tehran) and Dmitry Jakovenko (Khanty-Mansiysk), a single FIDE Presidential nominee – Anish Giri, and two more rating qualifiers – Peter Svidler and Leinier Dominguez.

So that leaves us with the following 16 players, including the line-up for each Grand Prix:

PlayerFedQualifyingRatingRankBaku 2014Tashkent 2014Teheran 2015Khanty 2015
Caruana, FabianoRating List28013xxx
Grischuk, AlexanderRating List27894xxx
Nakamura, HikaruRating List27827xxx
Karjakin, SergeyRating List27778xxx
Vachier-Lagrave, MaximeWorld Cup 201327689xxx
Giri, AnishPresident Nominee275811xxx
Dominguez, LeinierRating List275613xxx
Mamedyarov, ShakhriyarRating List275612xxx
Gelfand, BorisRating List274817xxx
Jakovenko, DmitriAGON Nominee274718xxx
Svidler, PeterRating List273222xxx
Andreikin, DmitryWorld Cup 2013272231xxx
Radjabov, TeimourAGON Nominee271733xxx
Kasimdzhanov, RustamAGON Nominee270643xxx
Tomashevsky, EvgenyWorld Cup 2013270146xxx
Ghaem Maghami, EhsanAGON Nominee2591254xxx

Some brief talking points:

1) Is the Tehran Grand Prix significantly weaker than the rest?

It may just be a coincidence, but one thing that jumps out at you from the list above is that the event in Tehran – the most “exotic” location – is being skipped by three of the top four rated players. How does that affect the average ratings?

Baku: 2748.92
Tashkent: 2739.42
Tehran: 2728.58
Khanty Mansiysk: 2745.83

Well, although Tehran is indeed 11 points weaker than the next weakest event all four of the tournaments nevertheless qualify as Category 20 – 2726-2750 – though the gulf may widen once Fabiano Caruana’s new rating kicks in on the official October rating list.

2) Will Ehsan Ghaem Maghami play against Boris Gelfand?    

Ghaem Maghami (left) warmed up by winning the recent 2014 ECO Cup in Tehran | photo: official website

Although Boris Gelfand is understandably skipping Tehran, Ghaem Maghami will be paired against Gelfand in Tashkent and Khanty-Mansiysk. In 2011 Maghami was expelled from the Corsica Masters after refusing to play against Ehud Shachar on political grounds. So will the Iranian host city nominee agree to play against the only Israeli (if not the only Jewish) player in the event? Or will Gelfand win by a forfeit against by far the lowest-rated player.

3) Aronian and Kramnik face a qualification battle

Vladimir Kramnik picked up $120,000 and a qualification spot he didn't need by winning the 2013 World Cup  | photo: Anastasiya Karlovich, World Cup website

The very top players have always treated the Grand Prix with a degree of distain. Why tie yourself down to unstable events with relatively low prize funds in (sometimes) unglamorous venues unless you really need to? This time round, though, it might dramatically reduce the chances of the 2014 Candidates Tournament favourites Levon Aronian and Vladimir Kramnik making it to the 2016 event. Aronian’s rating has taken a battering in recent weeks, while Kramnik has actually dropped out of the Top 10. If they fail to qualify on rating all that would remain is an organiser nomination or the FIDE World Cup – Vladimir Kramnik did manage to win that event in 2013, but getting to the final of knockout events is not an easy trick to repeat. 

Of course by 2016 there’s also a question mark over whether Kramnik will still be an active player at all.

4) No Topalov

Talking of which… perhaps one of the biggest surprises on paper is the absence of former World Champion Veselin Topalov, the winner of the last Grand Prix series and a man now up to world no. 5. He was on FIDE’s initial list, but chose not to take part, despite the fact he’s never been a fan of the rapid chess required to have a chance in the World Cup.

His decision was less of a surprise, however, if you’d watched our Olympiad coverage, where he explained his doubts about the Grand Prix and his ambitions after finishing last in the 2014 Candidates Tournament in Khanty-Mansiysk:

For instance, from 8:30 onwards Topalov comments:

Objectively speaking at the moment I think Magnus is just a different class. My ambition now is to try and get in again as a candidate, but it depends a little on the next cycle. I don’t know if I will play the FIDE Grand Prix. First they have to announce it and then I’ll see, but I didn’t like the first two so much, because they were always changing cities and contracts were very unclear. I assume it depends a little bit who wins the election.


5) Russia choose Jakovenko

This should be the least surprising decision imaginable – Russia, who have a 6-player battalion in the Grand Prix – choose to nominate a player rated no. 4 in Russia and no. 18 in the world. It wasn’t quite so straightforward, though, since despite originally being nominated for the 2014 Olympiad Jakovenko was later replaced by Ian Nepomniachtchi. Jakovenko made his disappointment with that decision known, but clearly didn’t upset too many people and now has three tournaments to make his mark – gold dust for top players like him who still can’t command supertournament invitations.

6) Moscow turns into Khanty-Mansiysk

It wouldn't be the FIDE Grand Prix series without a few last-minute alterations. The Russian capital city listed as the final venue for May 2015 has now turned into Khanty - which we assume means the chess capital city of Khanty-Mansiysk. That may also have favoured Jakovenko, who is, if not quite a local (he was born in Omsk) then at least a native of Siberia.

You probably wouldn't choose to walk...

Do you have your own observations on the line-up? Should Wesley So have been tried in place of Anish Giri? And who's going to win? The first Grand Prix of the new series starts on 1 October in Baku.

See also:


Sort by Date Descending Date Descending Date Ascending Most Liked Receive updates

Comments 2

Guest
Guest 5418389210
 
Join chess24
  • Free, Quick & Easy

  • Be the first to comment!

Register
or

Create your free account now to get started!

I am aged 16 or older.

By clicking ‘Register’ you agree to our terms and conditions and confirm you have read our privacy policy, including the section on the use of cookies.

Lost your password? We'll send you a link to reset it!

After submitting this form you'll receive an email with the reset password link. If you still can't access your account please contact our customer service.

Which features would you like to enable?

We respect your privacy and data protection guidelines. Some components of our site require cookies or local storage that handles personal information.