Reports Oct 2, 2014 | 9:47 PMby Colin McGourty

Baku GP, Round 1: New city, same Caruana

Fabiano Caruana came into the Baku Grand Prix with the “first world problem” of how to defend his sky-high new 2844 rating, but if he was feeling the pressure he didn’t let it show. The Italian beat world no. 8 Sergey Karjakin to move within just 15 points of Magnus Carlsen, while 46-year-old veteran Boris Gelfand scored the day’s only other win, pummeling Dmitry Andreikin in a 22-move miniature.

The stage of the Baku Grand Prix | photo: Maria Emelianova, official website

Baku Grand Prix Round 1 results

Dominguez Perez Leinier27510.5-0.5Kasimdzhanov Rustam2706
Tomashevsky Evgeny27010.5-0.5Grischuk Alexander2797
Karjakin Sergey27670-1Caruana Fabiano2844
Gelfand Boris27481-0Andreikin Dmitry2722
Nakamura Hikaru27640.5-0.5Svidler Peter2732
Mamedyarov Shakhriyar27640.5-0.5Radjabov Teimour2726

30-move draws

For the new FIDE Grand Prix series the old rule banning draw offers completely has been replaced with a requirement to play at least 30 moves first. Four games ending drawn at, or around, that mark can hardly have been a coincidence, though not all 30-move draws are created equal! Let's take them in turn:

Mamedyarov 1/2 – 1/2 Radjabov

This was one case where the action didn't heat up after the players appeared... | photo: Maria Emelianova, official website

The pairing of the local Azeri players against each other in Round 1 of the Baku Open was apparently met with a round of applause during the Opening Ceremony, but you didn’t need to be Nostradamus to predict the result. The first game to finish saw Shakhriyar and Teimour trade down into a drawn rook ending on which the curtain fell the moment the required number of moves had been made.

Tomashevsky 1/2 – 1/2 Grischuk

Alexander Grischuk is currently world no. 4 | image: live broadcast

There were three more draws that looked similar on paper, but only the all-Russian encounter between Evgeny Tomashevsky and Alexander Grischuk could count as a relative non-event. Grischuk found a precise path to defuse all the tension in the position.

Dominguez 1/2 – 1/2 Kasmidzhanov

This encounter turned on a moment of high drama, when Rustam played the unfortunate 25…Rc8??

26.Ne7+! simply wins the exchange, but the Cuban no. 1 missed his chance with 26.a4?

Did Rustam's withering stare prevent Leinier from finding the winning blow? | photo: Maria Emelianova, official website

Anastasiya Karlovich asked Dominguez when he spotted his mistake:  

It was immediately after I played a4. I saw I had Ne7 and of course I realised I could have played it one move earlier. It happens…

How did he handle that blow?

I didn’t have time to really get upset or anything. I had to make my next move. It was also the reason why I didn’t play on [at the end]. I was in a bit of time trouble and under pressure.

The time control with no increment – still in the Grand Prix regulations despite the majority of players being opposed to it – may have let Kasimdzhanov off the hook at the end, though you should take it with a pinch of salt when the chess24 contributor, former FIDE World Champion and conqueror of Naiditsch, Ivanchuk and Kramnik in consecutive rounds at the recent Olympiad talked about his ambitions for the Grand Prix:  

Objectively my opponents are a bit stronger than me, a bit more experienced than me... I don’t have some goals I could share with you, really.

Nakamura 1/2 – 1/2 Svidler

Both players saw the funny side of Nakamura's morning spent watching Svidler's videos | photo: Maria Emelianova, official website

A few weeks ago in a Q&A session Peter Svidler talked about how his chess24 video series on the Grünfeld Defence had complicated his life:

Playing the Grünfeld with Black these days there’s an additional level of danger because people might know even more about it than they do normally.

That might have seemed like a mere plug for our products (incidentally, you can watch the whole series and much more for a 9.99 Euro monthly membership ), but he was deadly serious, as the following exchange in today’s post-game press conference made clear:

Hikaru Nakamura: I played d3 on move 6, which is not what I normally play. I had a certain idea in mind before the game, not with e4, and then a friend of mine told me Peter had done some videos on the Grünfeld on chess24, so basically I wasted 2 hours this morning watching videos instead of preparing…

Peter Svidler: My audience is getting scarier and scarier!

Nakamura: I did this and then decided to change and do something different where I’d get a game, but ok, I don’t think the result was very good, to say the least!

Svidler: The funny thing about this is I actually spent a week three weeks before this tournament recording videos on this position, so in order to dodge the videos this was probably not the best pick! It’s a very playable line, but I wasn’t as unprepared as I normally am.

Although Svidler had been filming a repertoire for White he’d lamented the fact Black was doing so well everywhere, and sure enough he soon came out on top. In the end, though, the complex struggle ended with a draw agreed in 32 moves.

Svidler was asked afterwards if he thought allowing draws after move 30 was a problem, but he felt the “new crop of players” had no issues with a lack of fighting spirit:

You don’t need to make them more bloodthirsty - they’re naturally bloodthirsty!

Nakamura, meanwhile, was clearly happy simply to have escaped. Asked about his Grand Prix ambitions he admitted he wasn’t looking too far ahead for now:

I don’t think I’ve played a good game of chess in maybe 30 games...

A bad day for 24-year-old Russians looking to emulate 24-year-old Carlsen

So that brings us to the day’s two decisive games, which went badly for the class of 1990.   

Gelfand 1-0 Andreikin

Boris Gelfand, still fighting for another shot at the World Championship title | photo: Anastasiya Karlovich, official website

It’s a good job Dmitry Andreikin qualified for the Grand Prix series (as a World Cup finalist), as otherwise you wonder when we’d ever see him at the chessboard again! His only classical games in 2014 were in the Candidates Tournament, where he shrugged off a bad start to finish in a creditable 5th place. Since then we can only assume he’s been enjoying fatherhood, since he appeared unaware of recent developments in one of his pet lines.

Boris Gelfand, a deep theoretician and still a workaholic despite being the field’s veteran at 46, was the last person Andreikin needed sitting opposite. Gelfand explained he’d found 7.cxd5! after a game he played against Vugar Gashimov, but he'd been disappointed others played it first:

I was waiting and then some games appeared, so I never expected to have the chance to play it.

19-year-old Spanish GM David Anton looks at how Gelfand flawlessly converted his opening edge:

1. d4 e6 2. c4 ♘f6 3. ♘f3 b6 4. g3 ♗b7 5. ♗g2 c5 6. d5 exd5 7. cxd5 This clearly came as a surprise to Andreikin. The main line is Nh4, which Gelfand himself had played, while Ng5 has also been fashionable of late.

7. ♘h4 g6 8. ♘c3 ♗g7 9. ♗g5 (9. O-O O-O 10. cxd5 d6 is the other option, and there's still a lot to play for.) 9... O-O 10. ♕d2 ♕e8 11. ♗xf6 ♗xf6 12. ♘xd5 ♗xd5 13. ♗xd5 ♘c6 14. ♘f3 ♖b8 15. ♖c1 ♘b4 16. b3 ♘xd5 17. ♕xd5 ♕e6 18. ♖d1 b5 19. cxb5 ♖xb5 20. O-O ♕xe2 21. ♖d2 ♕e6 22. ♕xd7 ♕xd7 23. ♖xd7 ♖a5 24. ♖d2 c4 25. bxc4 1/2-1/ 2 (25) Gelfand,B (2739)-Gashimov,V (2761) Wijk aan Zee 2012

7. ♘g5 h6 8. ♘h3 b5 9. ♘c3 bxc4 10. ♘f4=

7... ♗xd5 8. ♘c3 ♗c6 The best retreat. On b7 the bishop would be left undefended and it would be easier for White to create threats.

8... ♗xf3 9. ♗xf3 ♘c6 10. O-O ♗e7 11. ♕a4+/=

9. e4 d6

9... ♘xe4 10. ♘xe4 ♗xe4 11. ♕e2 ♕e7 12. O-O ♘c6 13. ♗f4 White has a lot of compensation for the two pawns, making this position very dangerous for Black to play. 13... f5 14. ♖fe1 g6 15. ♘g5 ♗xg2 16. ♕c4 ♗e4 17. ♘xe4 fxe4 18. ♖xe4+− 1-0 (43) Krasenkow,M (2633)-Socko,M (2440) Stockholm 2013

10. O-O ♗e7 11. ♘h4 g6 A novelty, but the alternative that had already been played is no better.

11... O-O 12. ♘f5 ♘bd7 (12... ♖e8 13. ♗f4 ♗f8 14. ♗xd6 ; 12... g6 13. ♘xe7+ ♕xe7 14. ♗f4 ♖d8 15. ♗g5± ) 13. ♘xd6 ♘e5 14. ♘f5+/=

12. ♗h6 ♗f8 13. ♗xf8! ♔xf8 Black now has huge problems on the dark squares. The d6-pawn is weak and the e5-break is in the air.

14. ♕d2± ♘e8 15. ♖ad1 ♔g7 16. f4 Black's position is already lost. His king is badly placed, there are weaknesses and above all he's just too far behind in development.

16... ♕c8 17. ♘d5 ♖f8 18. e5! dxe5 19. f5 ♕d8 20. f6+ ♘xf6 21. ♘f5+ ♔h8 22. ♕h6 ♖g8 23. ♘xf6 A great game by Gelfand. He achieved an opening advantage with the very interesting and little-used idea 7. cxd5 and then crushed his opponent with some fine dynamic play.


Karjakin 0 – 1 Caruana

Fabiano Caruana yet again staking a claim to be the world's best player at this particular moment in time | photo: Maria Emelianova, official website 

And so we come to the day’s crucial game. The players had drawn in their last encounter – and the last game for both players – in the final round of the European Club Cup in Bilbao. In Baku, meanwhile, there was a winner, though not the one you might have predicted from the way the opening went. It wasn’t Fabiano’s finest hour, even if there was an amusing moment when commentator Emil Sutovsky wondered about Caruana's familiarity with his predecessors:

In the end, though, the clock and the lack of an increment would prove the crucial factors, with Sergey Karjakin putting too much trust in the somewhat erratic transmission of moves from the playing hall:

I can just explain a very unpleasant thing that happened to me. I went to the players' room and I was sitting, drinking, eating and I was looking at the translation [broadcast]. Fabiano was thinking, thinking, thinking, and he already had 11 minutes left. Then I decided to go to the playing room and I saw that Fabiano had already made a move and he had 25 minutes or something. I just lost 15 minutes because of this stupidity, and then I needed those minutes very much.

David Anton takes a look at the game:

1. ♘f3 d5 2. d4 ♘f6 3. c4 e6 4. ♘c3 ♗e7 5. ♗f4 O-O 6. ♖c1 ♘bd7 7. cxd5 exd5 8. e3 c6 9. h3 In theory this position is considerd better for White, who's managed to plant his bishop on f4 and has easier piece play.

9... ♘e4 The best way to arrange the pieces. The typical approach with Re8, Nf8 and Ne6 is very slow since the bishop can simply drop back to h2 and White has a more harmonious position.

9... ♖e8 10. ♗d3 ♘f8 11. O-O

10. ♗d3 ♘df6 11. O-O ♗f5 12. ♘e2 After the game Caruana noted that this move was a novelty, although Karjakin claimed to be unaware of the fact.

12... ♘d7 Since the white knight has left the firing line Black retreats his own knight to d7 in order to prevent the annoying Ne5 followed by f3.

The boss! | photo: Anastasiya Karlovich, official website

12... ♘d6 In the post-game press conference Karjakin pointed out the following amusing line: 13. ♗xd6 ♗xd3 14. ♗xe7 ♗xe2 15. ♗xd8 ♗xd1 16. ♗xf6 ♗xf3 17. ♗xg7 (17. gxf3 was given by Caruana as a better ending for him) 17... ♗xg2 18. ♗xf8 ♗xf1 19. ♔xf1 ♔xf8 and the bishops have totally cleared the board finally perishing!

13. ♕b3 Caruana said he'd missed this move.

13. ♘e5 ♘xe5 14. ♗xe5 ♖e8 15. f3 ♘d6=

13... ♕b6 14. ♕c2 ♗g6 15. ♗h2 ♖fe8 16. ♘f4 ♗d6 17. ♘xg6 ♗xh2+ 18. ♔xh2 hxg6 19. g3 Black has managed to simplify the position and is already close to equalising completely.

19... ♕d8 20. ♔g2 g5 I think it was better to keep the pawn back on g6 and a knight on f6. As played by Caruana Black has overly weakened the light squares.

21. ♖h1! ♕e7 22. b4 Well-played. It won't be easy for Black to defend his kingside and queenside at the same time.

22... a5 Remaining passive with a6 wouldn't be in Caruana's style.

23. b5 c5 24. h4! g4 25. ♘g5 Now Caruana could do with that pawn on g6.

25... ♖ac8 26. ♗xe4 dxe4 27. ♕b3 It was better to play

27. ♖hd1! c4 28. d5±

27... g6! The idea is to prepare f6, for which the king first needs to be on g7.

28. ♖c4 b6

28... a4 29. ♖xa4 ♘b6 30. ♖a7 c4 31. ♕d1 f6 32. d5 fxg5? 33. ♕d4 ♘d7 34. ♖xb7 ♖cd8 35. hxg5

29. ♖hc1 The rook was better on d1, but Karjakin already had the idea of sacrificing on c5.

29... ♖cd8 30. dxc5 ♘xc5 31. ♖xc5 bxc5 32. ♖xc5 ♖c8 The position is equal, but White needs to be precise not to end up worse.

33. ♖e5 Allowing Black to exchange a pair of rooks.

33. ♖d5! ♖cd8 (33... ♖ed8 34. ♖e5 ) 34. ♖c5=

33... ♕f6 34. ♖d5 ♖ed8 35. a4 A bad blunder by Karjakin.

35. ♖xd8+ ♖xd8 36. ♕c2 a4! and White suffers a little, but should hold.

35... ♖xd5 36. ♕xd5 ♖c2 Caruana: 

It was only after Rc2 I realised I was winning. I was happy about the exchange sacrifice as I felt I couldn’t be worse afterwards, but before that I was very worried.

37. ♔h1 ♖xf2


It wasn’t a beautiful game, but as Fabiano Caruana told La Gazzetta dello Sport in a recent interview when asked the old question about whether chess is a sport, art or science:

I’m certainly not an artist. Chess is a sport – a competition between two people. You have to win, not create art. If you win no-one looks at how, and if you lose no-one considers you an artist. The great players nowadays are very pragmatic.

Asked about his recent success in the post-game press conference, he commented:

I really have no idea, actually. Everything has just been going well. These things happen and you sometimes don’t know why.

So Caruana is off to yet another flying start, but funnily enough we already have a “top-of-the-table” clash in Round 2: Caruana-Gelfand. 

Don’t miss that and all the other games live here on chess24 starting at 15:00 local time (11:00 London, 12:00 Paris, 06:00 New York).  

Sort by Date Descending Date Descending Date Ascending Most Liked Receive updates

Comments 1

Guest 10165055261
Join chess24
  • Free, Quick & Easy

  • Be the first to comment!


Create your free account now to get started!

By clicking ‘Register’ you agree to our terms and conditions and confirm you have read our privacy policy, including the section on the use of cookies.

Lost your password? We'll send you a link to reset it!

After submitting this form you'll receive an email with the reset password link. If you still can't access your account please contact our customer service.

Which features would you like to enable?

We respect your privacy and data protection guidelines. Some components of our site require cookies or local storage that handles personal information.

Show Options

Hide Options